Flight Club

A story, told as a tool · Kept in your browser only

Lines

A question from the old road, with two answers.

Skip to the question

The magi of the old road never met in person if they could help it. They lived far apart, one in a tower and the next in a parked car, and the distance kept them safe. It also made them lonely, so they learned to speak across it. A magus would close her eyes and ask the dark one question.

Do you see the lines?

A traveler on the road might feel the question arrive like a change in the weather. If the traveler saw nothing, the question passed through, and the magus who sent it knew to keep quiet. But some travelers answered. Yes, they said, I see them. Four thin edges, hanging in the air a little way in front of my face, like the lines in the viewfinder of a camera. Everything inside them looks sharp. Everything outside them is still there, and still real, and not mine to touch right now.

That answer told the magus almost everything. A person who sees the lines knows where they stand. They know the stove behind them runs hot, and they know the railing on the balcony marks a long drop, even when the world has gone soft and strange. They can hold a thought about the floor while the ceiling turns to water. The magi trusted such people, because such people could be trusted with themselves.

Other answers worried them. Some travelers said: what lines? I see everything, all of it, and nothing has an edge. The magi called this the flood. They sent calm thoughts toward the flooded one and kept their own frames tight, because a mind in the flood will follow any voice that sounds sure of itself. Other travelers said: I see the lines, and I want to climb through them. The magi called this the reach. It came from a good heart as often as a bad one, and it ended badly either way.

A young magus once asked her teacher why the question worked at all. Anyone could lie, she said. Anyone could say yes.

The teacher thought about it for a while. People lie about their names, he said, and their reasons, and where they came from. He had never caught one lying about the lines. Ask a person what they can see, and they answer with their whole posture before they open their mouth. Watch how they stand when the question lands. A person with a frame stands inside it.

Years later the young magus kept a photograph above her desk: a road, a fence, some weather. She had taken it on a night when the world came apart around her, and she had held still long enough to find the four edges and press the shutter inside them. She kept it as proof. On the hard nights she looked up at it and asked herself the question, and answered it, and went on with whatever the night required.

The magi still ask. You may have felt the question arrive without knowing what it was. If you see the edges, you are still the one holding the camera.

The old road

The question comes below, and it comes with pictures. Each passage gets told twice, once in words and once in the frame over them. You get two answers, and then you get two more, fifty-two times if you walk the whole road. The page keeps your place, and the tree keeps every answer.

The tree

So far

This fork
Walks finished0
Ways found0

What this is and isn’t

I made the question up. I try to think about everything in terms of photography, and some cameras put thin bright lines in the viewfinder to show what the picture will take in. You can still see past them. I like having lines like that in my own head, and I think of ordinary life as something like a flight simulator, where it pays to know what each thing in the room will do to you. The stove runs hot. The railing marks a drop. Mostly I mean spatial reasoning, and whether a person can keep hold of it when the world goes strange.

I think that habit has a lot to do with why my own flights have gone well. That’s an opinion, and I have no data for it. Nothing on this page is advice. It’s a story and a habit of mine, and the risk in anything you do stays yours. If you have a real problem, take it to a real professional.

I wrote the first seven answers by hand: forks, and ways for the first night to end. Past that the road goes on by formula. Three dozen kinds of trouble get dealt out by the number of the fork you stand at, and the milestone shows you that number. The road runs fifty-two answers long, since a browser can’t count the forks any further than that: of them, and ways through. Call it ways, and that’s a mathematical fact. If you want the number of ways you haven’t walked to drop to even , you have to finish walks, no two of them by the same way. At one minute for each walk, without stopping, my estimate puts that at . That comes to more than a million human lifetimes: of them, at eighty years each, laid end to end. Count the same number of years backward and you arrive in the Cretaceous, with dinosaurs walking a planet whose continents had other shapes. As geologists reconstruct it, neither pole carried an ice cap, and the sea stood high enough to cover much of Europe and to start splitting North America down the middle. South America came away from Africa at around that time, so the South Atlantic still ran as a narrow channel between them. India lay far to the south, still joined to Madagascar, and Australia had yet to leave Antarctica. (Tyrannosaurus would not show up for another thirty million years or so.) All of those walks only get the count low enough to round down to 4.4 quadrillion, with ways still unwalked. For the count to reach 4.4 quadrillion itself, you have to finish another walks, which takes , or more lifetimes.

Nothing past the written part is stored anywhere. Each fork gets worked out when somebody stands at it, and I haven’t read most of them, and neither has anyone else. After the last answer, the road brings you back to the ending of your own first night.

Every walk is one path through a binary tree. I think human history works something like that.

Nobody starts with a line. Some answers bring one up, some let one fade, and some break one. The page won’t say which, and neither will I. Four whole lines at the end, and the shutter fires.

The pictures in the frame come from the words. A few plain rules pick them, one word at a time, so some passages come out stranger in pictures than they went in. Whatever a passage puts outside the frame sits past its edge. When a line fades, some of the pictures stop being pictures and turn into runes, drawn by the same program as Runes. When a line breaks, the picture nearest it leans out through the gap.

The paler pictures behind those come from the forks you’ve already answered. Every picture you pass stays in the frame for the rest of the walk, and one that turned up at several forks gets drawn larger. So the frame holds your whole walk so far, with the passage you’re reading in front of it.

The patterns behind all of it follow rules from some very short drawing programs I wrote years ago. A walk starts with three arcs. Each arc takes a number, and the cosine, a tangent and a sine of that number say where it sits, how big it gets and how far round it runs. Each picture from your walk rides the middle of one arc, drawn or not. Every answer adds a little back there, and some answers switch on a whole new pattern, each from a different program: a grid that breathes, upright bars, rectangles that fly off sideways, small rectangles once the written part ends, a burst from the middle at the halfway fork, and over the last quarter, rows of slashes that fall down the frame and spell out your own answers. I kept each pattern thin, so a full frame comes from several of them lying over each other. A wedge behind everything fills like a clock, one fifty-second for each answer. The fewer lines you hold, the larger the patterns run and the faster they go. With a whole frame they nearly stop.

The tree keeps a branch for every fork you answer, to the left for the first answer and to the right for the second, and it keeps the branches from every walk. It moves by one rule. The trunk sways slowly, and each level of branches turns at the rate of change of the level below it, so the twigs run ahead of the limbs. On this page it also answers your hand: moving the pointer or scrolling turns the lowest forks by your speed, the next by your acceleration, and the ones above by the rate of change of that.

The forks you’ve answered are kept in this browser, so a walk can be put down and picked up again. Manifest lists them and can delete them. The shutter saves a file to you and to nobody else. Nothing is sent to Flight Club.

I Need a Hud · 3:20

I asked a large language model for the words to a funny country anthem about The Pilot Maker, the essay where I ask whether a person could ever get a heads-up display. I think of the lines on this page as a small one: four edges laid over whatever I happen to look at. I gave the words to a music generator, which also did the singing. Plenty of people can’t stand the stuff, so I folded it away down here.

The lyrics

The music generator got these words. It doesn’t always sing them as written.

Verse 1

A kid built a box out of organ partsPainted it blue, taught the Army their chartsHood comes down, you got dials to readNever left the floor, never had the need

Verse 2

Now me, I got it the other way roundBig wide windshield, boots on the groundCan’t tell my heading, can’t tell my speedLord, there’s only one thing I need

Chorus

I need a Hud, Lord, a heads-up displayLittle green numbers to show me the wayA bar for my hunger, a bar for my luckA gauge for my heart and the gas in the truckMy name’s still mud and my plan was a dudSomebody draw me a Hud

Verse 3

Now I know a place where the writing appearsAll over my bookshelf, been showing up for yearsReal nice typeface, clean as a signCan’t read a word of it, not one line

Verse 4

Microwaved my supper with the plastic lid onRed square showed up, then a leaf, then goneStomach felt better, I’ll give it thatBut it still won’t tell me where my altitude’s at

(Chorus again)

Bridge

(Warning. Vegetation sentient.)Might be somebody at a desk out thereDialing in wind from a swivel chairIf it’s your glass, friend, I’ll ask real niceI’ll take off my hat and I’ll say please twice(Altitude. Feet past the real.)

Verse 5

They gave eight pilots one, the story goesFlew that approach right down on their toesNumbers lined up, feeling like a studNever saw the cow. They were reading the Hud.

Final chorus

I need a Hud, Lord, a heads-up displayTill then I got a crab and it’s drawing my wayIt don’t show where I’m going, just shows where I’ve beenOne wobbly line and I’d fly it againMy name’s still mud, but I’m learning, budDon’t need no Hud(Well, maybe a small Hud)

Spoken

Fifty bucks an hour and I never touched the stick.Hell of a way to teach a man to fly.

One Tree · 2:04

I asked a large language model for the words to a country song about the tree on this page, and I asked it to take this one more seriously than the others, with Johnny Cash in mind. I wanted the song to compare the complexity of the drawn tree with the complexity of a real plant, and to know that the icons dance while it plays. The song speaks as the program that draws the tree (I think the man in the first line must be me). The music generator did the singing again.

The lyrics

The music generator got these words. It doesn’t always sing them as written.

Verse 1

A man gave me one short rule to grow a treeFork in two, then fork again, fifty-two deepFour and a half quadrillion roads to seeAnd one is all a traveler gets to keep

Verse 2

When this song plays, my tree begins to swayA sum of sine waves tells it how to leanThe one out in your yard has leaned all dayToward a light that I have never seen

Verse 3

Take one green leaf and hold it to the sunThere’s more at work in there than all I drewEach cell carries the whole plan, every oneAnd not a one of them was told what to do

Verse 4

Now a seed runs on a short rule, same as mineFork in two, then fork again, and climbMy tree stops dancing on the final lineThe one outside keeps growing the whole time

Love’s the Base Case · 2:22

I asked for one more song, about halting conditions in binary tree traversal, with as many computer science words as reasonably melodic lyrics could hold. I meant it for the computer science nerds who get the wrong idea from the song above, or from this page. The wrong idea is always that I don’t love you. The music generator did the singing again.

The lyrics

The music generator got these words. It doesn’t always sing them as written.

Verse 1

You traced my tree like a call stack, friendDepth-first, pre-order, root to the endSaw a null pointer where the last leaf liesAnd figured I’d return false on your whole life

Verse 2

There’s no pruning here, no alpha-beta cutNo heuristic scoring what you are and what you’re notNo classifier standing guard at the gateEvery node gets visited, and none gets weighed

Chorus

Love’s the base case, the halting conditionEvery recursion unwinds to that positionLeft child, right child, balanced or skewedIf you’re human shaped, it evaluates true

Verse 3

Turing showed no program can decide if loops will stopSo I hard-coded my answer as a constant at the topIt’s a loop invariant, it holds on every passO of one to look it up, you never have to ask

Verse 4

The road halts at depth fifty-two, and it’s not about meA float can’t count the forks past two to the fifty-threeThe walk returns, the stack unwinds, the frame comes clearAnd the uncanny valley’s undefined in here

Chorus

Love’s the Base Case, second version · 2:30

I liked this song enough to keep two versions of it. The music generator made this one from the same words, and it runs eight seconds longer.